A California agent loses his license after nine 'unnecessary' annuity replacements to elderly clients
California's Insurance Commissioner revoked agent Alan Lucien Cerf's license in a decision effective in early 2019, after an administrative law judge found he had recommended nine "unnecessary" annuity replacements to elderly clients between 2007 and 2013, in violation of a state law written specifically to protect seniors from exactly this. Cerf was ordered to pay $49,683.15, calculated as the commission he personally collected on each violation, and had already been the subject of a 2003 stipulated order over similar conduct.
- Year
- 2019
- Where
- United States
- Outcome
- Sanctioned
- Victims
- 3
- Schemes
- Annuity switching and churning fraud
- Last reviewed
- 2026-11-12
The facts, as recorded
- The California Department of Insurance's Third Amended Accusation alleged that between 2007 and 2013, agent Alan Lucien Cerf sold multiple annuities to six different individuals, some of whom were seniors.
- An administrative law judge held a hearing over six days in August and November 2018 in San Diego, and found Cerf committed nine separate violations of Insurance Code section 10509.8, subdivision (a), by recommending 'unnecessary replacement' annuities to insureds older than 65.
- One client, who met Cerf in 2007 when he was 82, surrendered a Sun Life annuity (incurring an estimated $9,865 surrender charge) on Cerf's recommendation, then two years later surrendered the replacement annuity itself, incurring a documented $12,327 surrender charge on a transaction for which Cerf personally earned a $10,939.76 commission.
- A second client, who was 81 when he met Cerf in 2008 and 91 when he testified at the 2018 hearing, engaged in eight annuity transactions with Cerf over roughly five years; one of those transactions alone cost him a documented $3,146.38 surrender penalty.
- The administrative law judge found the 'egregious nature' of Cerf's dealings with these two clients, plus a third client's transaction, sufficient to justify revoking his license, and noted Cerf 'provided no character witnesses or references' and showed a 'complete failure to accept any responsibility.'
- Cerf had already been the subject of a stipulated disciplinary order in 2003 over related conduct, which put him 'on actual notice that he should be extremely careful to avoid recommending unnecessary replacements'; because that 2003 order did not establish admitted culpability for specific violations, the 2019 penalty was calculated as if these were first violations rather than repeat ones.
- The Insurance Commissioner ordered Cerf's license revoked entirely and ordered him to pay a total administrative penalty of $49,683.15, calculated as the commission he received on each of the nine violations ($19,035.68 for one client's two transactions, $25,647.47 for a second client's six transactions, and a flat $5,000 for a transaction on which an insurer had already rescinded his commission).
- The Decision and Order was signed January 25, 2019 and took effect 30 days later.
Why this case matters
This is an unusually well-documented example because it reached a full administrative hearing with sworn testimony, rather than settling, so the underlying conduct is described in detail by a neutral fact-finder rather than only alleged. It also shows the mechanism repeating on the same client more than once: one client was moved out of one annuity and then, two years later, out of its replacement too.
The same client, switched twice
One client first met Cerf in 2007 after responding to a mailed postcard. Cerf recommended surrendering an existing Sun Life annuity, which carried a 9 percent surrender charge, for a new annuity, a transaction that cost an estimated $9,865 in surrender charges. Two years later, Cerf recommended switching again, out of that same replacement annuity and into a third company’s product. That second switch alone cost the client $12,327 in surrender charges, on a transaction for which Cerf personally earned $10,939.76 in commission, roughly matching what the client lost.
Eight transactions in five years
A second client was 81 years old when he met Cerf in 2008 and 91 when he testified against him a decade later. In the first five years of the relationship, that client engaged in eight separate annuity transactions arranged by Cerf. At least one of those transactions, a 2009 transfer, cost the client a documented $3,146.38 surrender penalty on its own.
A prior warning that did not change anything
Cerf had already signed a stipulated disciplinary order in 2003 covering similar conduct. The judge who heard this later case found that the earlier order put him “on actual notice that he should be extremely careful to avoid recommending unnecessary replacements,” and that his conduct afterward “did not reflect a sincere commitment to change.” Because the 2003 stipulation had not specifically established admitted guilt on particular violations, the 2019 penalty was still calculated as though these were first-time violations, limiting the fine, even though the judge’s own language treated the conduct as a repeat pattern.
The caveat
This is a civil administrative license proceeding, not a criminal case; no criminal charges are stated in the source, and the outcome here is a license revocation and financial penalty, not a conviction or sentence. The accusation originally named six clients; the sustained violations described here involve three of them, and the other three are not detailed on this page because the source document does not establish that their transactions were found to be unnecessary replacements. The clients are not named here, consistent with this site’s policy of not naming victims.
Sources
- In the Matter of the License and Licensing Rights of Alan Lucien Cerf, Respondent (File No. CO201201306, OAH No. 2017020669). California Department of Insurance. Accessed 2026-11-12. Supports: All factual detail above: the 2007-2013 period, the six clients named in the accusation, the nine sustained violations of section 10509.8(a), the two clients' ages and transaction histories, the specific dollar figures for surrender charges and commissions, the 2003 prior order, the license revocation, and the $49,683.15 penalty calculation.