Wisconsin revokes an agent's license for five years over an unsuitable annuity and life policy sale to a retiree
Wisconsin's Office of the Commissioner of Insurance announced in October 2021 that it had revoked former agent Richard Freeland's insurance license for five years and ordered him to pay $27,206.16, after an administrative law judge found he sold a retired consumer an annuity and life insurance policy that were unsuitable given her age, her low risk tolerance and her limited financial means.
- Year
- 2021
- Where
- United States
- Outcome
- Sanctioned
- Victims
- 1
- Schemes
- Annuity switching and churning fraud
- Last reviewed
- 2026-11-12
The facts, as recorded
- The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI) announced on October 21, 2021 that it had charged former insurance agent Richard Freeland with violations of state insurance law related to the sale of an unsuitable life insurance policy and annuity to a retired consumer.
- Following a hearing before an administrative law judge, Insurance Commissioner Mark Afable determined that the way Freeland handled the consumer's annuity and life policy was 'without reasonable grounds and inconsistent with [the consumer]'s low risk tolerance, her age, her limited financial/investment sophistication, her limited fixed income or financial resources, her goal of preserving assets for her heirs,' and because the plan's success depended on a high-risk investment.
- Commissioner Afable ordered Freeland to forfeit to the state twice his commission from the transactions, plus $1,000 for each violation of insurance law found, for a total financial penalty of $27,206.16.
- Commissioner Afable also ordered that Freeland's insurance license be revoked for five years.
- OCI said the case began because the affected consumer herself filed a complaint alerting the department to the issue, and the department credited her directly for making the investigation and resulting action possible.
- The case was investigated and prosecuted internally by OCI staff, including Staff Attorney Lauren Van Buren and Advanced Insurance Examiner Renee Fabry, under General Counsel Richard Wicka.
Why this case matters
This case shows the regulatory mechanics of a churning sanction in unusual detail: the penalty itself, twice the agent’s commission on the transactions plus a flat per-violation fine, is calculated so the agent’s financial outcome from the deal is actively negative, not merely reduced. It also shows what actually triggers these cases: a single consumer’s own complaint to her state insurance department.
What the commissioner found
Rather than finding a specific lie or forged document, Wisconsin’s Insurance Commissioner found that Freeland’s annuity and life insurance recommendation was unsuitable on its face, measured against the consumer’s own stated circumstances: her age, her low tolerance for risk, her limited investment knowledge, her reliance on a fixed income, and her stated goal of preserving assets for her heirs. The plan also depended on a high-risk investment succeeding, a mismatch the commissioner’s order treated as sufficient on its own.
A penalty built to erase the profit
Rather than a flat fine, Wisconsin ordered Freeland to forfeit twice his commission from the transactions, on top of $1,000 for each separate violation, a structure that ensures a churning sale costs the agent more than it paid him, not simply less.
One complaint was enough
OCI’s own announcement credits the consumer who filed the original complaint with making the investigation possible, a reminder that these cases generally do not begin with a regulator’s own proactive audit, but with a client, or in other documented cases a family member, noticing something was wrong and reporting it.
The caveat
This is a civil administrative license proceeding, not a criminal case. The source does not name the affected consumer, and this page does not name her either, consistent with this site’s policy of not naming victims. The source does not state the dollar value of the annuity or life policy sold, or the surrender charges, if any, the consumer incurred, only the penalty paid to the state.
Sources
- Wisconsin Commissioner of Insurance Protects Consumers and Holds Former Insurance Agent Accountable. Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance. Accessed 2026-11-12. Supports: All factual detail above: Freeland's name, the October 21, 2021 announcement, Commissioner Afable's quoted findings on suitability, the twice-commission-plus-$1,000-per-violation penalty structure totalling $27,206.16, the five-year license revocation, the consumer complaint that started the case, and the OCI staff named as having worked the case.