Pennsylvania orders $117,559 refunded after a husband-and-wife agent team churns clients' annuities
Pennsylvania's Insurance Department announced in August 2019 that it had revoked the licenses of Pittsburgh-area agents Donald L. and Nicole P. Gilberg, a husband-and-wife team, after an investigation found they convinced clients to replace existing annuities with new ones, earning more than $136,000 in commissions while telling clients to ignore insurer letters questioning the changes. The department separately reached an agreement with the two insurers involved to refund a combined $117,559 in surrender fees to 25 Pennsylvania consumers.
- Year
- 2019
- Where
- United States
- Outcome
- Sanctioned
- Victims
- 25
- Schemes
- Annuity switching and churning fraud
- Last reviewed
- 2026-11-12
The facts, as recorded
- Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner Jessica Altman announced in August 2019 that her department had obtained more than $117,000 in restitution for 25 Pennsylvania consumers, many of them elderly, after an investigation into annuity sales by a husband-and-wife agent team, Donald L. and Nicole P. Gilberg, acting together.
- The department's investigation found the Gilbergs convinced consumers to replace annuities they had previously purchased with new ones, causing surrender charges on the original annuities and tying up the money for several more years.
- The Gilbergs made more than $136,000 in commissions on the replacement sales, from annuities issued by Oxford Life, based in Phoenix, Arizona, and Sentinel Life, based in Salt Lake City, Utah.
- Several scam victims testified they were never told they would incur any charges for replacing their existing annuities before they matured, and were told only that the new annuities would have higher interest rates.
- In some cases, consumers received calls or letters from the insurers questioning why they wanted to make the changes, but were told by the Gilbergs to ignore them.
- Both agents' insurance licenses were revoked after the department's investigation.
- The department reached an agreement with the two insurers to make restitution: Oxford Life refunded $67,559 that 17 consumers lost in surrender fees on its annuities, and Sentinel Life refunded $50,000 of the surrender fees eight consumers lost on Sentinel annuities, a combined $117,559.
- Commissioner Altman tied the case to Act 48 of 2018, signed by Governor Tom Wolf in July of that year, which added new annuity-sale disclosure requirements, including a 36-month look-back on whether a consumer has had another annuity exchanged or replaced, specifically, in Altman's words, 'to better protect unsuspecting consumers from being victimized by this "churning" of annuities.'
Why this case matters
This is the clearest documented example of the mechanism this scheme is named for: a regulator’s own press release uses the word “churning,” and describes the agents actively telling clients to disregard the one external check, a letter from the insurer itself, that could have caught the pattern earlier.
Told to ignore the warning
The insurers that issued the original annuities sent some clients calls or letters questioning why they wanted to replace policies they had bought relatively recently. According to Pennsylvania’s Insurance Department, the Gilbergs told those clients to ignore the warnings. Several clients later testified they were never told replacing their annuities would trigger any charges at all, only that the new annuities would pay higher interest.
The commission versus the refund
The Gilbergs collected more than $136,000 in commissions on the replacement sales. The two insurers involved, Oxford Life and Sentinel Life, later agreed to refund a combined $117,559 in surrender fees to the 25 consumers who lost that money, a restitution figure in the same range as what the agents earned selling the replacements in the first place.
A law written in response
Pennsylvania’s Insurance Commissioner tied the case directly to Act 48 of 2018, a law passed roughly a year before this case became public that added a 36-month look-back requirement specifically so an insurer or agent must consider whether a client had another annuity exchanged or replaced recently before recommending a new one. The commissioner’s own statement described the law as a response to this exact pattern, which she called “churning” of annuities.
The caveat
This is a civil regulatory and restitution action, not a criminal prosecution; the source does not state that either Gilberg was criminally charged. The 25 consumers are not named here, consistent with this site’s policy of not naming victims, and the source does not give the dollar amount any single consumer individually lost, only the aggregate $67,559 and $50,000 insurer-by-insurer totals.
Sources
- Penn. Insurance Department Announces Restitution for Consumers in Annuity Scam. Insurance Journal. Accessed 2026-11-12. Supports: All factual detail above: the Gilbergs' names, the August 2019 announcement, the more than $136,000 in commissions, the instruction to ignore insurer letters, the $67,559 and $50,000 restitution figures from Oxford Life and Sentinel Life, the license revocations, the Act 48 of 2018 disclosure requirements and look-back period, and Commissioner Altman's direct quotes including her use of the word 'churning'.