A Houston woman's twice-faked pregnancy at the same adoption agency
Jessica Felder, 35 or 36, told a Houston-area adoption agency and an adoptive family she was pregnant with twin boys, then kept collecting "living expenses" payments for months after she had miscarried without telling anyone. She pleaded guilty to aggregate theft of almost $20,000 from two adoption agencies and prospective parents, and in August 2019 a Harris County court sentenced her to two years in state prison, the maximum available under her plea.
- Year
- 2019
- Where
- United States
- Outcome
- Sentenced
- Reported loss
- $20,000
- Victims
- Not stated in the sources
- Schemes
- Adoption fraud
- Last reviewed
- 2026-11-14
The facts, as recorded
- Felder came to Houston-area agency Caring Adoptions claiming to be pregnant with twin boys and was matched with an adoptive family.
- Investigators believe she miscarried but did not tell the agency or the family, and continued collecting payments described as living expenses after the claimed due date had passed and no baby existed.
- She pleaded guilty in June 2019 to aggregate theft, admitting she stole almost $20,000 from two adoption agencies and prospective adoptive parents combined; one of those payments, $15,000, came from the Caring Adoptions family alone.
- Ahead of sentencing, Felder submitted eight character-witness letters seeking probation; prosecutors found five were fabricated, typed in the same font, unsigned, and in some cases written in the names of people who did not exist.
- A Harris County court sentenced Felder, hoping for probation, to the maximum available instead: two years in state prison.
- Harris County Assistant District Attorney Adam Broderick, of the office's Consumer Fraud Division, said it was the first time in any of his cases that a defendant had fabricated her own character-witness letters.
- Caring Adoptions executive director Stephanie Warren said she hoped the sentence would send a message to others considering similar schemes.
- The same Houston agency was separately targeted in 2019 by another woman, Amanda Aguilar, accused of taking $11,000 from a different family in 2016 using a pregnancy that was medically impossible because she had already had a hysterectomy; this is reported here only as a charged allegation, since no plea or sentencing outcome for Aguilar was found in sources this page could fetch and verify.
Why this case matters
This is the only documented case on this page resolved as a state theft charge rather than a federal fraud count, brought by a county prosecutor’s dedicated consumer fraud division rather than the FBI. It shows the same underlying scheme is viable at the scale of a single family and a single local agency, not only as a years-long, multi-state operation.
A scheme twice at the same address
That the same Houston agency was targeted by two different women using the same basic method, claiming a pregnancy and collecting living-expense payments, within roughly three years, suggests the agency’s own verification process, a signed doctor’s note rather than an independently confirmed pregnancy, was a known and repeatable weakness, not a one-time failure.
Fabricating the mitigation, too
Felder’s attempt to manufacture sympathetic character letters for her own sentencing, rather than simply accepting the consequences of the original fraud, is an unusual escalation: prosecutors described it as the first time they had seen a defendant forge her own references in any case in the division’s experience.
The caveat
Felder pleaded guilty to aggregate theft and has been sentenced; this part of the case is concluded, not an allegation. The related detail about Amanda Aguilar, mentioned above for context because she targeted the same agency with a similar method, is reported here only as a charge: no plea, conviction, or sentencing outcome for her case was located in any source this page’s research could fetch and verify, and she is presumed innocent of it.
Sources
- Woman learns her fate for faking pregnancy in adoption scam. ABC13 Houston (KTRK). Accessed 2026-11-14. Supports: Felder's identity and age, her guilty plea to aggregate theft of almost $20,000, the discovery that five of her eight character-witness letters were fabricated, her two-year sentence described as the maximum under her plea, and the quotes from Assistant District Attorney Adam Broderick and chief prosecutor Valerie Turner of the Harris County District Attorney's Consumer Fraud Division.
- Woman with hysterectomy accused of faking pregnancy to scam prospective parents. KPRC Click2Houston. Accessed 2026-11-14. Supports: Confirmation of Felder's two-year sentence and the $15,000 she took from the Caring Adoptions family specifically, the quote from executive director Stephanie Warren about not requiring an in-office pregnancy test, and the separate, charged-only allegation against Amanda Aguilar for an unrelated $11,000 scheme at the same agency involving a medically impossible pregnancy after a hysterectomy.