A Missouri day care operator's attempt to secretly place a client's infant for adoption

2019 United States Sentenced

Lasonya Faye Poindexter, a 31-year-old day care operator in Joplin, Missouri, used her access to a client's two children to try to arrange the adoption of their five-month-old daughter by a different family in Arkansas, fabricating a story that the infant's mother wanted a closed adoption because the child was the product of rape. The infant's actual parents never consented and were unaware. Poindexter pleaded guilty to wire fraud and was sentenced in February 2019 to six years in federal prison without parole.

Year
2019
Where
United States
Outcome
Sentenced
Reported loss
$1,500
Victims
2
Schemes
Adoption fraud
Last reviewed
2026-11-14

The facts, as recorded

Why this case matters

This is the only one of the four documented cases on this page where almost no money changed hands, because the targeted family refused to pay before the adoption was finalized, yet it drew the second longest sentence. It shows the scheme is prosecuted as seriously for the attempted, unauthorized transfer of a child as for the size of any payment collected.

A scheme built on an existing relationship, not a stranger’s pitch

Every other documented case on this page begins with a facilitator the family had never met before being approached. This one began with a caregiver the family already trusted with their actual children, showing the same underlying deception, invent a story that explains why a child is suddenly available, can ride on a relationship that has nothing to do with adoption at all.

How it nearly worked

The Arkansas couple had already met the infant in person, met Poindexter’s aunt as a go-between, and prepared a nursery, before a single, ordinary piece of due diligence, searching the claimed birth mother’s real name on Facebook, surfaced the photos that unraveled the entire story.

The caveat

Poindexter pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud and has been sentenced; this is a concluded case. The $1,500 restitution was ordered to the infant’s actual parents, not to the Arkansas couple, who are recorded here as a second victim in the sense that they were deceived and nearly received a child who was never legally available for adoption, not because they are documented to have suffered a financial loss.

Sources

  1. Joplin Day Care Operator Sentenced for Adoption Scheme. AM 1050 KSIS. Accessed 2026-11-14. Supports: The full mechanics of the case: the April 2017 start of the day care relationship, the Arkansas couple, the fabricated rape and closed-adoption story, the unauthorized interstate trips, the discovery through Facebook, the fake attorney email, Poindexter's guilty plea to wire fraud, and her six-year sentence without parole plus $1,500 restitution.
  2. Joplin day care operator sentenced to six years in prison for adoption scheme. The Turner Report (reproducing the US Attorney's Office, Western District of Missouri press release in full). Accessed 2026-11-14. Supports: The sentencing judge's name (US District Judge M. Douglas Harpool), the prosecuting Assistant US Attorney's name (Ami Harshad Miller), the investigating agencies, and the same case mechanics independently corroborating the KSIS Radio account.

If a legal outcome in this case has changed, please tell us and the page will be corrected. See the corrections policy.