Oregon bankruptcy court fines a hidden petition preparer $22,500 and bars him after he posed as an attorney by email
In a default decision on March 29, 2024, the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Oregon found that a non-attorney preparer and his company violated the Bankruptcy Code in a chapter 13 case for a couple facing foreclosure. The court found the preparer concealed his identity, gave legal advice, led the couple to believe he was a licensed attorney and used a different person's name in emails to the trustee. It ordered $22,500 in fines, $7,990 in damages and forfeiture of $3,995 in fees, and permanently enjoined the preparer in Oregon. The defendants did not appear.
- Year
- 2024
- Where
- United States
- Outcome
- Sanctioned
- Reported loss
- $3,995
- Victims
- 2
- Schemes
- Bankruptcy petition preparer fraud
- Last reviewed
- 2026-11-06
The facts, as recorded
- The U.S. Trustee sued Keith Bray and the Rezidential Group, Inc. under 11 U.S.C. section 110. After the defendants did not answer or appear, the court entered an order of default on November 13, 2023 and held an evidentiary hearing on damages and an injunction on February 15, 2024.
- The court found that the couple, facing foreclosure, were referred to the preparers by another group they had paid $2,000 twice, which told them it transferred no less than $2,000 of that money to the preparers. The couple then paid the preparers $1,995 more, and the court treated the fees charged as $3,995.
- The court found that the preparer told the couple bankruptcy could save their home and eliminate their debts, and that the couple believed he was a licensed attorney. He was not: the court found he had been disbarred in California in 2015.
- The preparer's company advertised litigation services and other legal services, which the court found violated the bar on preparers using the word legal in advertisements.
- The court found that the preparer prepared the petition and schedules, which the couple then signed and filed, without his name, address or required notice and disclosure on them, and that the petition's answer to whether a non-attorney had been paid to help was typed by the preparer as no.
- The chapter 13 trustee received the couple's plan from an email address bearing a real California attorney's name. The attorney told the U.S. Trustee he had no connection to the defendants, and the court concluded the preparer wrote the emails himself under that name.
- The court assessed fines of $22,500 (the $500 maximum per violation, tripled because the preparers did not disclose their identity), $7,990 in damages to the couple, forfeiture of $3,995 in fees, and a permanent injunction against acting as bankruptcy petition preparers in the District of Oregon.
- The court noted the U.S. Trustee had learned of several other cases filed with the defendants' help, including one with a pending adversary proceeding.
Why this case matters
It is the clearest look in the court record at how a preparer can look like a lawyer without claiming to be one. The court found the preparer used words such as “associates” and “partners,” gave advice no preparer may give, and had the couple copy a completed plan by hand onto a blank form, explaining that this was necessary because he was not licensed to practice law in Oregon. The couple never learned who was really behind their papers, according to the court.
The trustee noticed
The case surfaced because the chapter 13 trustee received a plan from an email address bearing a California attorney’s name. The trustee told the U.S. Trustee, who reached the attorney by phone through the state bar directory. The attorney said he had no connection with the defendants. A later reply to the U.S. Trustee said the address was an alias because the writer was scared to contact the trustee directly, and the court concluded the preparer wrote it.
The caveat
This is a civil sanctions decision, not a criminal case. It was entered by default: the defendants did not answer or appear, so the findings come from the U.S. Trustee’s evidence and the couple’s testimony without a contest from the defendants. The court’s own decision says it is specific to this case and not intended for publication or to have a controlling effect on other cases. The sources do not say whether the fines or damages were collected. The couple, the group that referred them and the attorney whose name was used are not named here. The $3,995 is the fees the court treated as charged; the couple also paid $4,000 to the referring group, of which, the court said, at least $2,000 reached the preparers.
Sources
- United States Trustee v. Bray et al., Adv. Proc. No. 23-3065-pcm (Memorandum Decision). U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Oregon (March 29, 2024). Accessed 2026-11-06. Supports: The default, the facts the court found, the violations, the $22,500 in fines, the $7,990 in damages, the $3,995 forfeiture, the permanent injunction, the preparer's disbarment, and the use of another person's name in emails to the trustee.