Also called: NEMT fraud · non-emergency medical transportation fraud · Medicaid ride fraud · wheelchair van fraud · Medicaid taxi fraud
Medicaid transportation fraud is billing a state Medicaid program for non-emergency rides to medical appointments that were never given or that did not qualify. Prosecutors have described claims for riders who were dead, in hospital or abroad, wheelchair vans used for walking riders, and kickbacks to members. Sentences in the cases here run from one year to 95 months.
What it is
Medicaid covers non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) so that enrolled people can get to doctors’ offices,
hospitals and other approved care. Transport companies are paid for the trips they provide. Medicaid
transportation fraud is billing for trips that were not provided, or that were not the kind of trip Medicaid
pays for. The cases here describe claims for riders who had died, riders in hospital, vans meant for wheelchair
users, and trips that existed only on paper.
How it actually works
The provider
A company is paid by a state Medicaid program for transporting members. In Massachusetts the company, Rite Way,
provided transportation services throughout the state that were covered by MassHealth. In New York, KJ
Transportation C Services Inc. was ultimately paid $20 million.
The riders
Claims need riders. The cases describe two sources: members recruited with cash kickbacks, as in the Rite Way
case, and members who received kickbacks in exchange for their Medicaid information, as in the KJ case. In the New Mexico case
the people listed as riders were a driver and her children.
The trip records
Each trip needs a record. In New Mexico, drivers signed trip forms falsely saying they had driven each other
to appointments, to disguise that they were driving themselves, and the company claimed that each passenger
in a vehicle had taken a separate trip. The New Mexico release also says many of the trips involved travelling
to Alcoholics Anonymous meetings across the state at great distances.
The claim
The company submits claims to the state, which pays them. Prosecutors described claims for members who were
hospitalized, deceased or out of the country on the date claimed, or who had never heard of the company, and
for wheelchair vans used by riders who did not qualify.
Where it could have stopped
In its 2021 audit of Massachusetts, the HHS Office of Inspector General recommended matching every claim billed on the day of an NEMT service against a corresponding qualifying medical service, and found that the state’s monitoring and oversight did not ensure that services were for qualifying medical services or adequately documented.
The payment
The money reaches the company and the people around it. In New Mexico the release says the company received
about $4,142,942 from Medicaid for the trips by the driver and her children, and that the driver received about
$980,901 from the company over four years.
The prosecution
The Massachusetts case began with a referral from MassHealth. Sentences documented here run from one year in
a house of correction to 95 months in federal prison, and a New Mexico driver has pleaded guilty and awaits
sentencing. In June 2025 New York’s Attorney General announced a takedown of 25 transportation companies.
Why it works
The program pays per trip. The claim is the product: a trip is billed, and the state pays on the claim. In
its 2021 Massachusetts audit, the HHS Office of Inspector General found that of 100 sampled claim lines, 86 did
not comply with certain federal and state requirements, and estimated at least 758,847 claims totalling
$14,142,730 across the state in 2016 and 2017. The audit counts improper payments, which are not all fraud.
Documentation was thin. For all 100 sampled lines, the audit found driver qualifications and vehicle
inspection, registration and maintenance policies or schedules were not adequately documented.
Real members, real identities. The cases describe claims in the names of members who were dead, abroad or
unaware of the company. The KJ summary says some members were paid kickbacks for their Medicaid information.
It is a known weak point. The HHS Office of Inspector General says prior audits have consistently
identified NEMT services as vulnerable to fraud, waste and abuse, and opened a new targeted review in October
2025.
Where it comes from
Entirely domestic: Medicaid is a joint federal and state program, and each state runs its own transportation
benefit. The documented cases are from Massachusetts, Illinois, New York and New Mexico.
The earliest conduct here. The Massachusetts Attorney General’s release dates the billing in that case
from April 2011 to September 2015. The New Mexico conduct ran from 2020 to 2026.
State enforcement is active. New York’s June 2025 announcement covered 25 companies in New York City, the
Capital Region, Western New York, Westchester County, Central New York and Long Island, with 16 companies
repaying more than $13 million.
Real cases
2026 US Convicted $4.0m
Dorothea Irving of Farmington, New Mexico, who worked as a driver from 2020 to 2026 for a non-emergency medical transportation company, pleaded guilty on July 20, 2026 to conspiracy to commit health care fraud. Court documents say she and the company submitted false trip records claiming that she or her children were the Medicaid beneficiaries without transportation. For those trips the company claimed about $3,957,788 and received about $4,142,942 from New Mexico Medicaid. A sentencing date has not been set.
Read the case file ·
1 source
2023 US Sentenced $8.5m
Julio Alvarado pleaded guilty to one count of health care fraud and on March 29, 2023 was sentenced by U.S. District Judge Kimba M. Wood in the Southern District of New York to 95 months in prison. He was ordered to pay $8.5 million in restitution and to forfeit $8.5 million. Supervising more than a dozen others affiliated with KJ Transportation C Services Inc., he submitted or caused to be submitted false claims for transportation of Medicaid beneficiaries, for which KJ was ultimately paid $20 million.
Read the case file ·
2 sources
2019 US Sentenced $4.2m
Michael Davini, 59, of Rindge, New Hampshire, owner of Rite Way LLC, pleaded guilty in October 2019 to larceny, Medicaid false claims and kickbacks charges. On November 4, 2019 a Worcester Superior Court judge sentenced him to one year in the House of Correction followed by five years of probation, with restitution of approximately $4.2 million. The Massachusetts Attorney General's office said that between April 2011 and September 2015 he repeatedly billed MassHealth for transportation that was never provided.
Read the case file ·
1 source
2017 US Sentenced $4.7m
Gregory D. Toran, 68, of Hazel Crest, Illinois, co-owner of a Chicago non-emergency medical transport company, was sentenced in federal court in Springfield, Illinois in January 2017 to five years in prison and ordered to pay $4.7 million in restitution for overbilling the Illinois Medicaid program by an estimated $4.7 million. The Associated Press reported that the overbilling included transport for some patients who had died. His co-owner, Tina Kimbrough, had been sentenced to 30 months in August 2016.
Read the case file ·
2 sources
Red flags
- A claim for a ride on a date the member was an inpatient in a hospital, or after they had died.
- A claim for a member who says they never used the company.
- Wheelchair van trips billed for riders who walk.
- Cash or gifts offered to members to take rides or hand over a Medicaid number.
- Trip forms signed by drivers for each other, or each passenger in one vehicle billed as a separate trip.
- Trips to destinations at great distances that do not match any treatment, as in the New Mexico case.
If it’s happening to you
If you are a Medicaid member and someone offers cash for your Medicaid number or a ride you do not need,
or you see a ride on a statement that you did not take:
- Do not accept money or gifts for your member number or for taking rides. The cases here treat kickbacks
to members as part of the scheme.
- Check your explanation of benefits or statements if your state sends them, and look for rides you did not take.
- Report it. See where to report; your state Medicaid agency and its Medicaid Fraud
Control Unit take reports.
- If you are a driver or employee, be aware that in the New Mexico case a driver pleaded guilty to conspiracy.
- Keep records of trips you did take, in case a claim is questioned.
Where the money goes
Entirely domestic in the cases here.
The state Medicaid program pays the transport company on its claims, which are partly federally funded; the 2021 Massachusetts
audit put the federal share of its estimated improper claims at $7,071,365 of $14,142,730. From the company, the
sources describe cash kickbacks to members, payments to a driver of about $980,901 over four years in New Mexico, and in
Illinois, restitution of $4.7 million and $4 million ordered against the two co-owners. The sources do not describe
how the rest was spent.
By the numbers
No published dataset breaks this scheme out as its own category yet, so there is no chart to show.
The data page explains which agency categories exist and why some schemes are
invisible in official statistics.
Every factual claim above traces to one of these. Statistics are reported losses; see
methodology for what that does and does not measure.