Also called: ambulance transport fraud · dialysis ambulance fraud · Medicare ambulance fraud · unnecessary ambulance transport scheme
Non-emergency ambulance fraud bills Medicare for stretcher-level transport of patients, often dialysis patients, who could have ridden in a chair or walked. Crews are told to leave out that the patient can walk. A Dallas owner got 15 years in 2010, and two Guam owners were sentenced in 2020 and ordered to repay more than $10.8 million.
What it is
Medicare pays for an ambulance only in a narrow set of circumstances. Medicare.gov says Part B covers ground
ambulance transportation when traveling in any other vehicle could endanger your health, and that in some
cases it may pay for medically necessary non-emergency transportation if a doctor or other provider has
written an order. Its example is someone with end-stage renal disease who needs a ride to and from a dialysis
facility.
Non-emergency ambulance fraud is billing that benefit for patients who did not meet it. The company sends
a stretcher-level, ambulance-priced trip for a patient who could have sat in a car, a van or a chair. The
claim is then supported by trip paperwork that omits what the patient could do. The patient normally pays only
20 percent of the Medicare-approved amount, which may be one reason a patient sees no cost in the extra ride.
How it actually works
A real benefit with a narrow rule
Medicare and TRICARE reimburse non-emergency transports to dialysis when they are medically necessary: the
Justice Department describes the test as the patient being bed-confined or unable to be moved any other way
without endangering their health.
A patient who needs the same trip again and again
In the Dallas case the companies
“primarily transferred patients on a non-emergency basis to and from dialysis treatments three times per
week.” Each patient is a repeating stream of claims.
The paperwork is shaped to qualify
The prosecutors in Dallas said the defendants told employees to omit facts when documenting transports,
“such as whether the patients walked to the ambulance.” In Guam, the owners instructed employees to remove
references to patients being able to walk. In Los Angeles, ProMed’s EMTs were instructed to conceal patients’
true medical conditions by altering paperwork and creating fraudulent documents.
The patient rides in a chair
The Dallas companies’ own records, the Justice Department said, showed many patients riding in a captain’s
chair in the back of the ambulance rather than lying on a stretcher. The vehicle is an ambulance; the
passenger did not need to be in one.
Where it could have stopped
The crew’s own trip record is the only evidence of the patient’s condition, and the people who controlled it were the defendants. A claim that is checked against the physician’s order, the patient’s actual mobility and whether the patient received treatment at the destination is harder to fake than a claim checked against the company’s own form.
The claim is submitted and paid
The company bills Medicare, and sometimes Medicaid or TRICARE. In the Dallas case the claims totaled more than
$3.5 million and payments exceeded $1.3 million; in Los Angeles, ProMed’s false claims came to at least
$1.5 million, with Medicare paying at least $804,755.
The money becomes personal spending
In the Guam case, the owners admitted using the scheme’s money for vacations, personal residences and personal
income taxes, and falsely categorizing those expenses as business expenses. The Dallas owner was convicted of
engaging in monetary transactions in property derived from unlawful activity.
Analysts and prosecutors catch up
The HHS Office of Inspector General analyzed 7.3 million ambulance transports from the first half of 2012 and
reported that about one in five suppliers had questionable billing, concentrated in a few metropolitan areas.
Prosecutions followed years after the conduct: the Dallas sentence in 2010, the ProMed sentence in 2015 and
the Guam sentences in 2020.
Why it works
The benefit depends on one fact about the patient, and the company controls the record of it. Whether a
patient needed a stretcher is written down by the crew employed by the company that gets paid. When the owner
tells the crew what to omit, the claim looks complete.
Scheduled treatment creates repeat claims. In the Dallas case patients were carried to and from dialysis
three times a week, and each trip is a claim. The repetition is what lets a modest per-trip payment add up.
The patient pays little. The patient pays 20 percent of the Medicare-approved amount, so a patient may
have little reason to question whether a van would have done. This page does not claim that patients
participated knowingly; no case here charged one.
The volume looks normal. Medicare paid $5.8 billion for ambulance transports in 2012, nearly double its
2003 payments, according to the HHS Office of Inspector General. Against that background, one company’s
dialysis runs do not stand out until someone examines the records.
Detection takes years. The Los Angeles conduct ran from about 2008 to 2012, and the documented sentences
came between 2010 and 2020.
Where it comes from
A US scheme built on US federal and military health programs.
Scale runs from small to large. ProMed in Los Angeles billed at least $1.5 million; the Dallas companies
more than $3.5 million; Guam Medical Transport more than $10.8 million, which the Justice Department called
one of the largest single Medicare ambulance fraud cases it has prosecuted; and Alpha Ambulance in Los
Angeles was charged with more than $49 million in claims.
It clusters in places. The HHS Office of Inspector General found that more than half of the questionable
transports it identified were for beneficiaries living in four metropolitan areas, and the documented cases
here are from Dallas, Los Angeles and Guam.
It is run by owners. Every case here involves the company’s owner or owners, supported by managers. The
cases named a billing manager and a supervisor of EMTs in Los Angeles and a director of operations in Dallas.
Real cases
2020 US Sentenced $10.8m
Clifford P. Shoemake, 63, and Kimberly Clyde "Casey" Conner, 60, owners of Guam Medical Transport, were sentenced to 71 months and 63 months in federal prison after pleading guilty to conspiracy to commit health care fraud and conspiracy to engage in monetary transactions with the proceeds of unlawful activity. The Justice Department said they received Medicare and TRICARE reimbursements for non-emergency dialysis transports that were not medically necessary. They were ordered to pay back more than $10.8 million.
Read the case file ·
1 source
2015 US Sentenced $804,755
Yaroslav Proshak, 47, owned and operated ProMed Medical Transportation, which provided non-emergency ambulance services to Medicare beneficiaries in the greater Los Angeles area, many of them dialysis patients. A federal jury convicted him in August 2015 of conspiracy to commit health care fraud and five counts of health care fraud, and on December 7, 2015 he was sentenced to nine years. His billing manager and an EMT supervisor each received two years. The evidence at trial showed at least $1.5 million in false claims between May 2008 and October 2010, on which Medicare paid at least $804,755.
Read the case file ·
1 source
2014 US Sentenced
Aleksey Muratov, 32, and Alex Kapri, 56, owned and operated Alpha Ambulance Inc., a now-defunct Los Angeles area company that specialized in non-emergency ambulance transportation for Medicare beneficiaries, primarily dialysis patients. Judge Audrey B. Collins sentenced Muratov to 108 months and Kapri to 75 months after both pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit health care fraud. When the four people tied to the company were charged in October 2012, prosecutors alleged more than $49 million in false claims to Medicare between 2008 and 2012.
Read the case file ·
2 sources
2010 US Sentenced $1.3m
Muhammed Nasiru Usman, 50, of Arlington, Texas, owned and operated Royal Ambulance Service, Inc. and First Choice EMS, Inc., which mainly carried patients to and from dialysis three times a week. A federal jury convicted him in May 2010 on all 14 counts, including conspiracy to commit health care fraud, 12 counts of health care fraud and one count of engaging in monetary transactions in property derived from unlawful activity. On October 13, 2010 Judge Jorge A. Solis sentenced him to 180 months and ordered $1,317,179 in restitution. Prosecutors said the companies submitted more than $3.5 million in fraudulent claims to Medicare and Medicaid, resulting in payments of more than $1.3 million.
Read the case file ·
1 source
Red flags
- An ambulance arrives to take you to a routine appointment, and you can walk or sit up. Medicare covers ambulance transport when traveling in any other vehicle could endanger your health.
- You ride in a seat instead of on a stretcher. In the Dallas case the company’s records showed patients riding in a captain’s chair.
- A crew asks you to sign a form that describes you as more ill or less mobile than you are, or a company seems unconcerned about whether you can walk.
- You get a Medicare statement for ambulance trips you did not take, or for more trips than you remember.
- A company offers you transport “at no cost to you” and asks for your Medicare number.
- The company never asks for a doctor’s order, though non-emergency transport generally needs one.
If it’s happening to you
- Read your Medicare statements and compare each ambulance claim with the trips you actually took.
- Ask the company what it is writing down about your condition and do not sign blank or inaccurate trip
forms.
- Call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) to ask about a claim, or report suspected health care fraud to the
HHS Office of Inspector General at oig.hhs.gov.
See where to report for other countries.
- Ask your doctor whether you actually need ambulance transport, and whether a wheelchair van or car would
work. Do not stop going to dialysis; if you need a ride, ask your dialysis center about transport options.
- If you work for an ambulance company and are told to leave something out of a trip record or to change
it, keep a copy of the instruction and report it. Every case on this page began with an instruction from
an owner or manager who was later sentenced.
- Keep your own records of dates, destinations and how you traveled.
Where the money goes
Medicare pays the ambulance company, not the patient. The documented cases show the money going to the owners
and, in Guam, to personal spending dressed as business expenses: vacations, personal residences and personal
income taxes. The Dallas owner was convicted of engaging in monetary transactions in property derived from
unlawful activity, on top of the health care fraud counts.
Recovery comes through restitution orders and prison terms years later. In Dallas the court ordered restitution
of $1,317,179; in Guam, the owners were ordered to pay back more than $10.8 million; in the ProMed case the
article reports restitution of $804,755 per defendant.
By the numbers
No published dataset breaks this scheme out as its own category yet, so there is no chart to show.
The data page explains which agency categories exist and why some schemes are
invisible in official statistics.
Every factual claim above traces to one of these. Statistics are reported losses; see
methodology for what that does and does not measure.